Long Island Transportation Alliance

  • Blog
  • About
  • 2019 LI Bike Parade
  • Crash list year 1
  • Crash list year 2
  • Take Action
  • Gallery
  • Useful links
  • Events
  • News
  • Social Media
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • Press
  • Education
  • Membership

Photo credit: Bill Larsen

Failure to yield pedestrians when turning is actually a crime

October 20, 2015 by Sylvia Silberger in Sylvia Silberger blog

This morning I received a Google alerts email about the 21st crash that seriously injured or killed a pedestrian or cyclist on Long Island since September 13th of this year. This crash took place on Horseblock Road in Medford at 7:45 Monday morning and left cyclist Julien Robinette critically injured. 

The motorist who injured Robinette was attempting to take a left from the southbound lane and collided with Robinette, who was riding north in the northbound lane.  If this had been an automobile accident, the driver would have been at fault for cutting in front of northbound traffic during the turn, but for this incident no charges were filed. 

Charges were filed in only two of the twenty-one crashes this month, both of which were suspected DUI's.  Five of the crashes were hit-and-runs, the perpetrators as yet not apprehended. No reported charges were filed in any of the other fourteen crashes. In fact, in all but three it was specifically reported that no charges were filed, this last crash being among those.

On my bike ride home from work last night along Hempstead Turnpike, I was in a situation very similar to the one that left Robinette critically injured yesterday morning. There was a pedestrian walking the other way who was also almost a casualty.  As I was nearing the intersection of Surrey Lane, heading west, I noticed a tow truck hurrying toward me with his blinker on, clearly intending to turn into Surrey Lane in front of me. I slowed down because it was clear he had no intention of giving me the right-of-way to which I was legally obligated and I had no intention of fighting him for it. At the same time there was a pedestrian heading east on the sidewalk who was just getting to Surrey Lane. The pedestrian was not facing the tow truck and did not notice that the tow truck was turning in front of him. The truck did miss the pedestrian, but barely.  It was close enough that the pedestrian jumped back some.

From what I've seen this month, it seems that as long as the driver was not intoxicated and didn't leave the scene, he wouldn't have been charged if he had hit me or if he had hit the pedestrian.

Drivers who ignore cyclists and pedestrians when turning should be charged and they should be ticketed even when there is no crash. Negligence should be charged.

The photo above is of me waiting at the corner of Old Country Road and Glen Cove Road.  My husband Bill and I went there specifically to take pictures because we didn't have to worry about who to give photo credit to for traffic scenes. However, at this particular time, I have the light to cross Old Country Road, but there were so many vehicles taking rights in front of me that I did not get into the intersection before the countdown was over. This was the worst case of all the experiments I did at that crossing, but in every single one of them, when I tried to cross from south to north, I had to wait for so many turning cars that I barely made it across before the countdown.  Here is a video of one of those crossings.

To be certain, I believe many of the motorists who turned in front of me at the Old Country Road/Glen Cove Road intersection during that day of filming were doing so because they were intimidated by the entire culture around that intersection, not because they wanted to cut me off.  They did so because they were afraid of getting honked at or even rear-ended. They may have even been afraid that if they were to stop and wait for me, the car behind them might race around them and hit me. I have had cars pass me while I was waiting for a pedestrian to cross at a crosswalk more than once on Long Island. During that day of filming there was actually one motorist who tried to wait for me to cross, but he was honked at and quickly went on again before I had a chance to.  

We cannot let a few very aggressive drivers dictate the culture of driving on Long Island. Most of us want to live in a friendlier place.

We, as Long Islanders, need to make a concerted effort to remind motorists that it is their responsibility to watch for pedestrians and cyclists, but we also need to start really enforcing the existing laws that protect pedestrians and cyclists.   

 

October 20, 2015 /Sylvia Silberger
bicycle commuting, cycling, pedestrian safety, cyclist critical injuries, cycling safety
Sylvia Silberger blog
3 Comments

Photo credit:  Bill Larsen

Letter to Newsday Sent 10/11/2015

October 19, 2015 by Sylvia Silberger in Sylvia Silberger blog

(The letter below was sent to Newsday on Sunday of last week, 10/11/2015. A shorter version of it showed up in the October 21 paper. Thank you, Newsday!)

Dear Newsday,                                                                                         October 11, 2015

I was heartbroken by your article about the Smithtown doctor, Dr. Kenneth Rich, who was killed by a vehicle on Friday evening (http://www.newsday.com/long-island/suffolk/kenneth-rich-killed-by-dodge-charger-driven-by-timothy-burke-suffolk-police-say-1.10944247). I applaud that you took the time to write about and personalize the victim of this horrible event. I am, however, bothered that this doesn’t happen more often.

Since September 14th I’ve been keeping my own log of traffic crashes with pedestrians and cyclists in Long Island that result in critical injury or worse.  You might be surprised to hear that in just the 27 days since I’ve been keeping this list, there have been a total of ten fatalities and five critical injuries! You can see the full list here http://www.car-lessli.org/crash-list/ .

As far as I can tell from the usually very short news blurbs I find about these crashes, only two were caused by a drunk driver: this one and a fatality in Carle Place on October 1st.  The others were simply crashes that were barely reported; just unfortunate victims of a traffic infrastructure that is outrageously dangerous for those of us who attempt to commute without a car, many of whom do not have the means to commute in any other way.  In all of the other fourteen crashes, the only information I could find on the victim was his or her age, name and hometown, if even that.

My list starts on September 14th when a 48-year-old Hempstead woman, Elzire Presume, was killed crossing Sunrise Hwy. Who was Ms. Presume? Did she leave a family? Why was she a pedestrian in Massapequa on that tragic day? Was she just out taking a stroll, or returning from work or maybe from shopping?

Choosing randomly, I see the fourth victim on the list is 24-year-old Farmingdale University student Eyyad Almargi, of Yonkers, who was killed the evening of September 17th,  in Farmingdale. Ironically, this is the very day of the Car Free Long Island Day rally at Farmingdale University. Who was Mr. Elmargi? What was his major; what were his ambitions? How are his parents and friends coping with his untimely death just as he was beginning to blossom into an adult? Why was he risking his life as a pedestrian on that day?

I could ask the same question of every single victim on that list other than Dr. Rich, but doing so would make this letter too long to publish. I am afraid that it already is.

Long Island is deadly for cyclists and pedestrians and we need to do something about it. We need a significant investment in infrastructure such as bike and pedestrian lanes or paths, preferably away from traffic. We also need an emphatic public awareness campaign about vehicular responsibilities towards cyclists and pedestrians. I, myself, have almost been hit by a vehicle on several occasions, two of which stopped in horror when they realized that they almost hit me. The fact that there might be a pedestrian in the crosswalk they were turning into or racing through at a stop sign just never occurred to them. The existence of pedestrians and cyclists needs to be on the minds of every driver in Long Island. We should never have another month with ten fatalities and five critical injuries on Long Island, and we need to recognize and memorialize all of the victims of these crashes.

Sincerely,

Sylvia Silberger,

Founder, Car-less Long Island

October 19, 2015 /Sylvia Silberger
pedestrian deaths, Dr. Kenneth Rich, Elzire Presume, Eyyad Almargi, cyclist deaths, cycling safety, Letter to editor, pedestrian critical injuries, pedestrian safety
Sylvia Silberger blog
1 Comment
  • Newer
  • Older